13 Comments
User's avatar
Frank Modica's avatar

I'm not sure we're looking at a single driver here. Consumers definitely look back on prices. We can debate how long that look back is, but it seems to be more than one year. If you look at a 2-yr inflation measure it's still elevated at the beginning of 2025. Still, at some point, the salience of inflation should begin to decline, but that's not happening, so that's insufficient to explain the continuing pessimism in the UMich sentiment. I suggest that an important missing factor is one DJT. No one likes chaos; not business and not consumers, and we've had a healthy dose of chaos and uncertainty in the last 15 months. Plus, while unemployment is still low, hiring is essentially frozen, and people are responding to that. These are fuzzy factors, not easily put into a model, but they're nonetheless real and consumer sentiment is itself a fuzzy measure.

Partha's avatar

The identity of the missing factor is perhaps not just DJT, but all that DJT represents - glib promises unfulfilled, lack of accountability, eagerness to convert a democratic system into a virtual dictatorship and general lack of character/trustworthiness. It would be nice, but perhaps impossible, to be able to boil all this down to a single parameter.

Elie Canetti's avatar

I would think there’s an argument to be made that the suddenness of the jump in inflation against a background of long subdued inflation gives the price level a salience that it didn’t have in the 70s/80s. I’m old enough to remember those times and I grew up with high inflation as a constant background. Now, people have grown up with two percent (or less) as the norm, so perhaps their dissatisfaction is a kind of loss aversion (the loss of those halcyon days when one didn’t have to give much thought to prices). Beyond that of course is the social media noise encouraging people to be dissatisfied/angry (the anger is, of course, more justified than ever) and the extreme political polarization.

Jared Bernstein's avatar

Spot on. Here's a quote from the paper that Paul K picked up:

Our findings suggest that a huge storm after a long calm can be more upsetting to people who are not used to bad weather.

Add in, as you say, extreme polarization and doom-scrolling social media, and you get the result.

Norm Spier's avatar

Oh, man. On affordability, in the NY Times just yesterday, a particular propagandistic travesty on clear thinking on behalf of special interests has recurred, and I am annoyed about it, as I always am.

Within this article: https://www.nytimes.com/2026/04/16/realestate/were-building-more-affordable-housing-these-days-its-still-not-enough.html ,

paragraph two contains:

"From 2010 through 2024, construction of affordable — that is, income-restricted — housing grew by 73 percent, more than double the pace of market-rate apartments. In 2024, affordable units accounted for nearly 14 percent of newly completed rental stock, up from just 9 percent a decade earlier."

Did you catch that? No, not in the numbers. "Affordable housing" is taken to mean income-restricted housing.

(That's the housing that tends to be

a) expensive to build,

b) is highly subsidized by taxes, or hidden taxes taken as tax credits to corporations in exchange for paying for the housing, and/or market-rate renters,

c) is in shortage with waiting lists often of five or ten years,

and

d) that you can't get at all if your income is too high to qualify, but you still can't possibly afford the market rents or prices of purchasable houses in your area.)

Now, in normal English, affordable housing means something rather different. Just housing cheap enough to afford, which may come even from the market alone for many people, if you just make it legal for builders to build without too much hindrance. (Like restrictive zoning, and other things.)

So, we have one of those tricks played on many of the people without the critical thinking skills to be able to pick up on it. On this issue, many Democratic politicians play along. "Oh, you say you can't afford housing? Well, then, what you want is affordable housing. O.K. We'll give it to you, in the NY Times sense."

(Note this is the same exact technique applied by the Republican propaganda system, with "socialist Democrats", "lying Democrats". I'm really not sure of the exact terms they use. They are using a word-substitution technique to manipulate a susceptible class of people. One of these I caught not long ago, which is kind of cute, actually, is Scott Bessent referring to a "toxic Paul Krugman".)

I can't stand this stuff!

(Ezra Klein is at the Times. Maybe he can make them stop it!)

Goodman Peter's avatar

While affordability is the word of the moment, it elected a mayor in NYC, and is popping up more in Democratic electeds candidates speeches, it doesn’t translate into policies in the near term.

If T asked you for recommendations……

Norm Spier's avatar

1) When I click on the link to the UMASS Gamble talk, I get the paper, not the talk. (I get:

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1cx--TXGMHaSQi7rGW-hT31OvKIwmUKp_/edit#bookmark=id.nxf19m5idyui )

The video version of the talk can be found here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nc5Ep4pXkuM , though note you have to move the video up into well over 1.5 hours to get to the talk.

(It will eventually wend its way to here: https://www.umass.edu/economics/economics-events/philip-gamble-memorial-lecture , where you can, incidentally, find the other Gamble lectures going back to 2008.)

2) I, and other readers of both Krugman and Bernstein, did catch Krugman's little friendly lobbing at JB this morning of "Jared is too good an economist to be unaware of this puzzle".

(I wound of thinking of my Walter Lippmann quote, plopped down on JB just yesterday, https://econjared.substack.com/p/the-role-of-policy-in-forthcoming/comment/244368622 ,

where we have from Lippmann "[a public] ...is interested only when events have been melodramatized as a conflict".

I don't know whether this approach was used by PK to try to get perhaps 50 more people interested in this obscure question, up from some number, probably under 1000 people, of 160 million voters, who would be otherwise interested.

In case it helps drag in another 10 people, let me offer a bit of (false, sensationalist) tabloid fodder: "Many believe Krugman attacked Bernstein because of feeling angered at not being asked to deliver the Gamble Lecture himself, for what would have been his second time. As well, it was obvserved Krugman then picked a time, less than 14 hours after Bernstein finished the notoriously demanding and exhausting Gamble lecture, to spring the technical disagreement on him. Perhaps in order to catch Bernstein off-balance, and unable to defend his technical view quickly." (😊))

--

Good luck, J.B. My money is on you!

Jared Bernstein's avatar

Thanks for point out link fails! They should all be correct now. Boomer alert...

James Koch's avatar

How does consumer greed fit in with this developing econ screed?

Douglas Hall's avatar

Thanks for sharing the links to your Phillip Gamble Memorial Lecture, Jared. (You're in impressive company, as well you should be! https://www.umass.edu/economics/economics-events/philip-gamble-memorial-lecture). I had hoped to make it to UMass to see you in person, but alas had a meeting in one of the rural Western Mass towns. Looking forward to the forthcoming YouTube! Cheers, Doug.

ADIL SAYEED's avatar

I'm enjoying the discussion about this topic by you, Professor Krugman and GW Morris; and learning a lot.

Quick question: in your empirical work with Daniel Posthumus, do you do anything to adjust Index of Consumer Sentiment values from April 2024 to allow for the change in survey method implemented starting with that month?

Tedeschi and Cummings wrote about this in a Briefing Book substack post in 2024. "The effect of online interviews on the University of Michigan Survey of Consumer Sentiment". (https://www.briefingbook.info/p/the-effect-of-online-interviews-on)

Sorry if I have repeated the same comment. I tried to comment yesterday and posted in my own Notes instead. Two years since I've joined substack and I still don't quite have the hang of how to do things.

Mark Wheeler's avatar

“Sentiment” is highly subjective, so good luck trying to explain sentiment shifts by tracking the ups and downs in strictly economic measures, or even Presidential approval ratings. I’m more inclined to think that “sentiment” might cloak underlying feelings of fairness: “other people” are getting ahead bigly and I’m not. Stories about the wealth being amassed by the top 1% (and top 0.1%) hardly conjure up images of a level playing field. I haven’t looked, but how has the Gini Coefficient been tracking over the last couple of decades?

Robert Antall's avatar

In addition to inflation for a typical American middle-class family, the financial gains from Trump’s tax cuts are generally smaller than the added costs from tariffs—resulting in a modest net loss in many estimates. This explains a lot in terms of consumer sentiment. Prices going up while at the same time they get a tax increase makes affordability decrease. Of course this doesn’t apply to upper income individuals who got a bigger tax cut and spend a smaller percentage of their income on “necessities.”